‘Abuse’ of RTI has led to ‘paralysis and fear’ among officials, claims CJI Bobde

Main Justice of India Sharad Arvind Bobde on Monday claimed the unbridled use of the Proper to Details (RTI) Act had designed a perception of “paralysis and fear” in the govt.

“There is paralysis and concern about this Act (RTI). Persons are not taking conclusions,” Main Justice Bobde noticed orally.

The CJI stated government functionaries were way too fearful to even get any conclusions.

Senior attorney Prashant Bhushan, for activist Anjali Bhardwaj, said “only those who are corrupt have purpose to fear”.

The court docket was listening to an application filed by Ms. Bhardwaj and retired Commodore Lokesh Bhatra about the lack of transparency in the appointment procedure of details commissioners regardless of a judgment from the Supreme Court on February 15.

“We want to find a way to prevent the abuse of RTI Act. Really do not say as if there is no abuse,” Justice Bobde instructed Mr. Bhushan

The CJI explained time experienced come to lay down tips on the use of the RTI. Recommendations need to be place in position to verify the locus of the RTI applicant and place a “filter” on the kind of requests made below the 2005 Act.

Justice Bobde claimed the courtroom was not versus the workout of the appropriate to information and facts. “But it cannot be an unrivalled suitable. There is the critical problem of people today submitting RTI requests with malafide intentions, persons established up by rivals,” he claimed. The RTI Act experienced grow to be a resource of prison intimidation by people today with an axe to grind. “Criminal intimidation is a awesome word for ‘blackmail’,” Justice Bobde said.

Individuals who get in touch with by themselves “RTI activists” and had been in no way involved with the challenges on which they file RTI requests hade impeded govt working, the CJI observed.

“When I was in Mumbai, a government official said the Mantralaya is nearly paralysed mainly because of the variety of RTI requests designed… Have you observed the kind of people trying to get facts. Anyone can talk to. Persons describe by themselves as RTI activists. Is that an occupation?” Justice Bobde asked.

Justice B.R. Gavai, on the Bench, remarked that “people write ‘RTI Consultant’ on their letterheads”.

Justice Bobde mentioned the courtroom was prepared to hear arguments on the locus of persons who submitted RTIs and also about location up a “filter which can be rightfully employed”.

Meanwhile, More Solicitor Basic Pinky Anand submitted that an ad was posted for the publish of information commissioners on December fourteen. The research committee has just been constituted. “The needful would be performed,” Ms. Anand submitted.

The court docket directed the government to publish on its internet site the names of the users of the search committee established up in the approach of appointment of the Central Information Commission’s information commissioners.

Mr. Bhushan retorted that an advertisement was specified about 11 months in the past. A 2nd advertisement was basically an justification to delay appointments. “They will now have rationale to hold out for yet another 11 months,” Mr. Bhushan submitted.

The court docket gave Mr. Bhushan liberty to file a contempt petition towards the authorities, if essential, for alleged non-compliance of its February 15 judgment.

“We will difficulty detect if we obtain our judgment is not complied with,” the CJI explained.

The courtroom shown the case for listening to in February 2020.

You have attained your limit for free article content this thirty day period.

Register to The Hindu for absolutely free and get limitless accessibility for thirty days.

Membership Positive aspects Include things like

Today’s Paper

Come across cell-helpful edition of content from the day’s newspaper in just one easy-to-study list.

Unlimited Obtain

Enjoy reading through as quite a few posts as you desire with no any constraints.

Personalised suggestions

A decide on list of articles that match your interests and preferences.

Speedier pages

Go smoothly among articles or blog posts as our internet pages load quickly.


A one-stop-store for looking at the most current updates, and taking care of your preferences.


We temporary you on the most up-to-date and most vital developments, 3 occasions a working day.

Not certain? Know why you must shell out for information.

*Our Electronic Subscription plans do not at the moment incorporate the e-paper ,crossword, Apple iphone, iPad cellular apps and print. Our ideas increase your reading through knowledge.