The Winners and Losers of NFL Week seventeen – The Ringer


Each individual week this NFL year, we will rejoice the electric powered plays, examine the colossal blunders, and explain the inexplicable moments of the most latest slate. Welcome to Winners and Losers. Which a person are you?


Winner: The Conclusion of the NFL Season

There were being 256 frequent-time NFL online games this calendar year, and the race for residence-discipline benefit in the NFC arrived down to a few inches in the last seconds of the 256th.

Let’s start out at the conclude, with thirty seconds remaining in the NFC West–deciding matchup amongst the 49ers and Seahawks. If San Francisco gained, it would be the no. one seed and engage in home game titles until finally the Tremendous Bowl. If Seattle won, the Seahawks would participate in a house recreation subsequent 7 days, and the Niners would be the no. 5 seed, suitable to perform a household playoff match only if they received again-to-again highway games and hosted the no. six seed (who also gained back again-to-again highway video games) in the NFC championship video game. So, yeah, there was a good deal on the line.

Trailing 26-21, the Seahawks ended up driving for a get. The below play—a fourth-down throw to a player with zero occupation catches—was pretty much usual in contrast to what followed:

The catch by John Ursua saved Seattle alive by giving them a very first down, but did not earn them the match. It gave Seattle the ball at the one-yard line with 23 seconds remaining and no timeouts. But remaining deal with George Fant was limping right after the participate in, and struggled to get back to the line of scrimmage for the up coming snap. The Seahawks experienced no timeouts remaining, and couldn’t run a perform with an wounded remaining deal with, so they made the decision to spike the ball, supplying themselves a likelihood to reboot.

With about twenty five seconds remaining on the play clock, it is looks like the Seattle Health-related Staff members was running on to the discipline and Fant waives them off. Throws almost everything off. Russ thinks they may perhaps have re-established the participate in clock. #FantsFault pic.twitter.com/2XG7ECRcU9

— GrantLA (@GrantedLA) December thirty, 2019

Now, the clock seemingly wasn’t a factor—but personnel was. The Seahawks experienced the ball at the one-lawn line with the recreation on the line—just like they did in Tremendous Bowl XLIX, when they famously did not hand the ball to electrical power back again extraordinaire Marshawn Lynch. The good news is, Seattle experienced a possibility to right that wrong—the Seahawks thrilled the NFL earth by signing Lynch out of retirement very last week immediately after accidents to starting functioning back Chris Carson and backup C.J. Prosise.

But anything acquired screwed up. Maybe Pete Carroll invested a second also prolonged contemplating about regardless of whether to go to Lynch. Probably Lynch, who was signed literally days in the past and hadn’t been a aspect of the team’s two-minute drill installs, was not expecting to be called into the game. (It seemed like Lynch was putting on a hat rather of a helmet on the sidelines, and took time acquiring his suitable devices.) Despite possessing forty seconds to established up their future perform soon after the spike, the Seahawks had been known as for a hold off of game because of to the confusion more than Lynch’s entry. That moved the ball back to the five-property line. Soon after the match, at the very least a single Seahawk claimed the team had been organized to hand the ball to Lynch, but from the five-lawn line, they experienced to go.

Right after incomplete passes on next and 3rd down, the spike came back to haunt the Seahawks, who have been now facing a 2nd-straight fourth down for the division. Wilson threw to tight finish Jacob Hollister, who experimented with his ideal to will the ball into the end zone, but fell inches quick.

The aftermath of this was chaos. The 49ers acted as if Hollister experienced fumbled, and ran the ball back a hundred yards to the reverse conclude zone. The Seahawks argued that Hollister had really scored. Wilson’s elbow, for some reason, started gushing blood, and no person seemed to know or care why. Al Michaels and Cris Collinsworth carried on a polite conversation in the NBC booth about absolutely nothing in individual to cover the actuality that they had been just as clueless about what was going on as the rest of the earth.

This is how the NFL season ended, with a maelstrom of thrilling plays and baffling Pete Carroll possibilities. Really don’t be bummed the NFL year is over, even if, like me, your favorite four months of the calendar year are the four months when you expend every Sunday on a sofa with your most loved consolation food items, your aggravating fantasy groups, and the dulcet tones of Scott Hanson. It is not just that all excellent matters will have to occur to an end—it’s that some matters are gooddue to the factthey appear to an conclude.

If NFL fields had been unlimited, there would be no aim line, and the Seahawks and Niners wouldn’t have place just about every ounce of their effort and hard work into receiving Hollister throughout the objective line or holding him on the other aspect. If NFL online games had been countless, the ticking clock wouldn’t have existed, and Hollister’s push would’ve been just yet another enjoy in an everlasting struggle for points. And if the NFL season were countless, NFC West positioning wouldn’t have been so critical. I guess I’m unhappy the NFL period is over, but the perfect battle in its ultimate times makes me happy the close of the NFL time exists.

Loser: The New Orleans Saints

The Saints won their final video game of the year—dominated, actually, using a 35- guide on the Panthers in the 1st 50 percent and coasting to a forty two-ten win. But never get worried, the Saints still obtained screwed.

New Orleans went thirteen-three this yr, which is good sufficient to generate a 1st-round bye in practically each individual NFL period. But this 12 months, the Packers and 49ers also went into 7 days seventeen at twelve-three. Ifeitherworkforce dropped, the Saints would have gotten a initial-spherical bye. But the 49ers beat both equally the Packers and Saints in the frequent year, giving them the no. 1 seed in situation of a a few-way tie, and the Packers had the much better conference history, offering them the no. two seed.

The Packers fell into a 17-3 gap against the eliminated Lions—but outscored Detroit twenty-three down the extend to earn on a area intention as the clock expired:

Continue to, the Saints had a likelihood to get a 1st-spherical bye if the Niners missing. But, perfectly, all that things we talked about up there happened—plus a single point I didn’t point out. On third down, Wilson focused Hollister, but 49ers linebacker Fred Warner grabbed Hollister and prevented him from finding the ball:

Hypothetically, this play really should have been reviewed, since missed pass interference phone calls are reviewable this season—you know, simply because ofTHE Terrible Issue THAT Occurred TO THE SAINTS Last Year. The 1 positive of the Saints getting eradicated from the postseason for the reason that of a missed pass interference contact was that it induced the NFL to make go interference reviewable—except the rollout of that rule modify was so inconsistent and fraught that making go interference reviewable has commonly been considered as a destructive. The botched rollout of PI evaluation could’ve been redeemed if the NFL experienced stopped perform to guarantee that this missed contact in a pivotal engage in in a vital match was rectified. In its place, the recreation saved transferring, the Seahawks dropped, and the Saints have to engage in upcoming weekend.

Missing out on a initial-spherical bye is a actually large offer. It is not just that the Saints might eliminate to the Vikings next week—and they seriously might. It is that if they earn, they’ll have to perform on the street versus the Packers, and if they acquire that, they’ll probably have to engage in on the street versus the Niners. There’s a purpose just about every Super Bowl participant because 2012 has gotten a very first-round bye—it’s seriously challenging to get 3 straight online games in back again-to-back again-to-back again months. According toFiveThirtyEight,the Saints’ hopes of successful the Super Bowl would have jumped to 22 per cent with a Niners decline. As a substitute they fell to eleven per cent.

Because the NFL went to a 16-sport routine in 1978, just two 13-3 groups have at any time been forced to enjoy on wild-card weekend. The most new? The 2011 Saints, who lost their next-round activity to the Niners.

For the 2nd straight 12 months, New Orleans was screwed by a missed pass interference simply call, which led them to tie their very own record for the ideal crew to have to participate in 4 postseason games to get a championship. These kinds of is life for the Saints. Hey, at the very least LSU has very good juju this 12 months.

Winner: The Miami Dolphins

7 days 17 is a particular form of magic. The greatest groups in the league usually have the minimum to engage in for, while the worst look uncertain whether or not they must try out to earn or reduce. For some groups, it is the most vital week of the calendar year for some others, it’s just an bothersome obligation. You can never truly be sure which groups will show up. The matters that come about truly feel like they just take spot in some form of alternate dreamworld. The online games from time to time appear to be forgettable—and that’s why every single calendar year, something happens that I’ll by no means fail to remember.

One particular purpose the Patriots are in the Super Bowl virtually every single yr is simply because they typically have to participate in one particular considerably less playoff video game than most teams. Their complete dominance of the AFC East usually means they’ve experienced a very first-round bye in each of the very last nine seasons, offering them 1 much less hurdle en route to a championship. All the Pats needed to do to get one for a tenth straight 12 months was beat the Dolphins in Week 17.

The Dolphins.A team that, before this yr, many believed had the probable to be the worst in NFL history. Just after all, there have been situations this time when the Dolphins ended up on speed to rating less points than any workforce in NFL history and also enable additional factors than any crew in NFL history—and that was just before they made a decision to get started investing absent their number of gifted players for upcoming draft picks. They were the deal with of NFL tanking, epitomized by their forty three- reduction to the Patriots in 7 days two, a match in which the Dolphins scored zero touchdowns but threw two interceptions that were being returned for touchdowns. It seemed fewer like an NFL video game and far more like a 7 days one school football activity the place Large Condition paid out Directional Tech $1.eight million to get their asses kicked.

The Dolphins did change factors all-around above the system of the yr, improving upon to 4-eleven getting into Week 17, which is just a standard Poor Group File and not a historic disgrace. But continue to, the Patriots ended up obviously envisioned to win. They were being 17-issue favorites, a playoff-bound team with motive to continue to keep participating in, going up against a crew that could only harm its draft place by winning.

But 7 days 17 is a weird land—so unpredictable that even the trivial industry of fantasy soccer feels too critical to be made a decision by such strange performances. On paper, Miami had very little to enjoy for. But on the subject, it appeared like they experiencedanythingto participate in for. And it’s possible they did. Like we said very last 7 days: Front places of work may tank, but players and coaches really do not, and the Dolphins clearly resented the thought that they would lay down on the industry. Week 17 provided an option to get back again at the crew that created them a laughingstock.

The Dolphins picked off Tom Brady for a landing to give by themselves an early 10- lead, with former Patriot Eric Rowe taking the ball into the conclude zone for a score:

Miami wide receiver DeVante Parker, labeled by a lot of as a bust, absolutely torched cornerback Stephon Gilmore, thought of by numerous as a beloved to gain Defensive Player of the 12 months. He finished with 8 catches for 137 yards, by far the most any receiver experienced this time from the Patriots:

Ryan Fitzpatrick had 320 passing yards and threw the video game-winning touchdown:

The Dolphinsdidhave something to perform for. Rowe, and the a lot of other Dolphins gamers and coaches who arrived more than from New England with head coach Brian Flores, desired to show they could be beneficial outside the house of New England’s procedure, that they hadn’t just been cogs in the Bill Belichick equipment. Fitzpatrick is 37 yrs aged, and has no drive to assistance the Dolphins get a larger select in future year’s NFL draft so they can better decide on his substitution. They may well not have required a get in the common feeling like the Patriots, whose postseason positioning could be enhanced by an on-subject result—but they experienced causes to participate in.

Miami’s 27-24 win is the major upset in terms of point distribute because 1995. It is far more than just a late-year oddity, simply because now the Pats will have to enjoy on wild-card weekend, a circumstance which drastically damages their hopes of repeating as champions. Right before Sunday’s reduction to the Dolphins, the Patriots experienced a 10 percent opportunity of successful the Tremendous Bowl, for eachFiveThirtyEightafter the decline, that dropped to 3 p.c.

Week seventeen is a specific sort of magic, and you never know what it will provide. This year, a group that appeared like it could be 1 of the worst of all time handed the finest dynasty in the record of the sport their most important setback in a ten years.

Winner: Jameis Winston’s Terrible, Lovely History

Jameis Winston died as he lived. Of training course, he lived by dumping barrels of kerosene around himself and leaping into fireplace pits. When you live like that, you kind of be expecting to die like that.

Before this week, I wrote about how Winston experienced the opportunity to make historical past in Week 17. Not only could he become the eighth quarterback at any time to toss for 5,000 yards in a season—a excellent document!—but he could grow to be the to start with quarterback at any time to have thirty touchdowns and 30 interceptions in the similar period, and the first quarterback with 30 interceptions in a season because 1988—not precisely good records.

Winston hit 5,000 yards without having substantially problems, passing that mark in the next quarter. But he spent most of the activity caught on 29 interceptions. I was nervous. Did Winston not know that he was on the cusp of heritage?

Of class, there was no want to anxiety. Winston threw his thirtieth interception of the yr in the most spectacular style doable. When the activity went to extra time, Winston ensured that his initial go of the extra session would be the last move of his season by throwing a video game-ending decide-six:

Winston did not just hit the thirty-30 mark with the pick—he also established the all-time single-period history for decide on-sixes in a period with his seventh. He’s the initially quarterback to throw a wander-off OT pick-six since 2015, and the 1st quarterback to throw a time-ending OT select-six because Matt Hasselbeck’s well-known “we want the ball and we’re gonna score” decide-6 in 2004.

For persons who watch Winston just to see the interceptions, this was a perfect ending. Head mentor Bruce Arians, on the other hand, seemed positively fed up with the Winston experience:

Arians, requested if Winston throwing a choose-6 in overtime is worst doable way to end a period: “I can’t imagine of anything worse.”

— Greg Auman (@gregauman) December 29, 2019

Bruce Arians on Winston’s thirty-thirty period: “So a lot good and so a lot outright horrible.”

— Ryan Bass (@Ry_Bass) December 29, 2019

From an genuine football viewpoint, this was a rather disgraceful second. Winston setnumerousignominious information for failure on a sport-losing participate in that ensured his staff would complete with a getting rid of document. From the seems of it, Winston’s continued incapacity to toss passes to the right crew could be a big component as the Buccaneers choose irrespective of whether to retain him for 2020 and further than.

But I simply cannot recall a funnier NFL minute than a quarterbackplacing many ignominious documents on a video game-shedding perform that ensured his group would complete with a dropping history. It was not just a failure. It was a monument to the concept of failure, an argument that failing can be spectacular if gamers dream major plenty of. Like I mentioned, Winston died as he lived.

Loser: Freddie Kitchens

Freddie Kitchens had a person of the least difficult ultimatums in heritage. Ahead of Week seventeen, Browns possession was reportedly contemplating letting Kitchens hold his task with a gain about the 1-14 Bengals. It’s like giving a university student a passing grade for productively producing their title on the prime of the site.

It also defies all logic: This Browns season was an complete disaster, as a expertise-laden squad fell out of the playoffs with gamers begging to be traded and a star participant finding into screaming matches with Kitchens on the sideline. How could a victory in a meaningless video game from an terrible team mitigate a entire period of embarrassments?

Freddie failed the exam. Cincinnati exploded for 33 factors, together with a touchdown scored whilst the Browns had only 10 players onto the discipline:

The Bengals, who, like I said, experienced just one win in their very first 15 video games of the time, ran circles around the Browns. Basically, in Andy Dalton’s circumstance, which is in particular upsetting, since he’s Andy Dalton.

It was a successful second for players from both franchises. The Bengals, who had by now secured the no. 1 select in the draft, no for a longer period had to offer with their admirers rooting towards them, and gleefully exploded with a prolonged-awaited victory. And the Browns, no for a longer period even hypothetically in the running for the playoffs, uh, didn’t seem particularly motivated to help you save Kitchens’s career. The decline would’ve been humiliating if it was not exactly what the workforce seemingly needed.

If Kitchens’s tenure arrived down to a single recreation, then which is a horrible determination, since it gave him the opportunity to preserve his occupation with a win that should’ve occur very easily. Luckily for the Browns, Kitchens created the final decision effortless. Understanding that his position was on the line, Kitchens’s group shed to the worst workforce in the NFL in a video game in which they forgot to on a regular basis put the appropriate quantity of gamers on the field.

The Kitchens era is more than. The ultimatum delivered by Browns management was only justified by the point that Kitchens unsuccessful. All Kitchens had to do was write his title at the best of the examination to pass, but he expended his time doodling all about the site rather.

Winner: Huge Person Touchdowns

It was a banner calendar year for massive soccer gamers scoring. Before this year, we highlighted a getting touchdown by 347-pound Vita Vea, the heaviest participant in NFL record to catch a touchdown. Past 7 days, we wrote about how there had been more touchdown catches by players 300 lbs or heavier than in any time in NFL historical past. But Sunday introduced a person more Significant Man touchdown document: The Falcons ran a deal with-qualified play to get 311-pound Ty Sambrailo this 35-yard touchdown.

Sambrailo’s rating was the longest touchdown reception by a player weighing a lot more than 300 kilos (and the longest landing reception by any offensive lineman) in NFL history.

Most passing touchdowns to offensive linemen are from within just the 5-garden-line—they’re primarily based close to the defense forgetting to include a lineman who declared as suitable for juuuuuust very long enough for them to get open up and catch a move. They’renotbuilt for that participant to catch the goAND THEN Run, since offensive linemen aren’t commonly superior at operating. The Falcons evidently did not treatment. They gave Sambrailo the ball and requested him to select up 22 yards after the capture.

Was it really? No. At a specified position, Sambrailo recognized defenders are getting on him, and experimented with to dash more rapidly, and realized hecannotsprint quicker. He’s a cargo van with a prime speed of eighty miles for each hour. He can smash that gasoline pedal all he wants it’s not going any more rapidly. But it doesn’t matter. The perform was drawn up perfectly sufficient that the cargo van hit the end line in advance of the System one racers powering him. As it turns out, a cargo van’s top pace is even now quite damn quickly.

2019 was the Year of the Big Person Landing. We observed large adult men showcase their array of talents in the acquiring match a lot more frequently than at any time, and in more distinctive techniques than ever. These may well be trick plays, and they may possibly not perform as a team’s base offense, but the linemen associated are gifted adequate to turn them into productive scores time and time again. The only detail that can make me happier than 2019 becoming the Calendar year of the Significant Male Landing is that the successes of these proficient significant men will lead to every subsequent calendar year currently being an additional Yr of the Huge Guy Touchdown.

Winner: Derrick Henry

Do jogging backs subject? Men and women on Twitter have viewpoints about this! My personalized reply to this dilemma is “maybe,” but I do know this: No operating again has mattered more in any just one activity than Derrick Henry did Sunday.

The Titans entered Sunday with a get-and-in playoff state of affairs. If they shed, they were likely however excellent, but if they conquer the Texans, they ended up confirmed a playoff spot. How’d they get that playoff place? By providing the ball to Henry, above and above and over yet again.

Henry had 32 hurrying attempts—the most of any player in any recreation all time long—and went for 211 yards—the next most of any player in any video game all year extended. He experienced three touchdowns, together with this fifty three-lawn score:

That fifty three-garden have did not just ice the 35-fourteen get and give the Titans a playoff spot—it pushed Henry earlier Nick Chubb of the Browns for the NFL hurrying direct. Chubb experienced entered the day with a 124-yard guide on Henry for the rushing title, but only experienced forty one yards in the Browns’ reduction to the Bengals.

To summarize: Henry had just about the very best operating sport of the season to power his group to the postseason even though starting to be the dashing champion. Do jogging backs make a difference? I never know—but from time to time, they can do magnificent items, and viewing gamers do awesome items is magnificent, and magnificent things issue.

Loser: Any one Who Experienced Derrick Henry on Their Fantasy Crew and Missing Very last Week When He Was Wounded and Had to Watch Him Go for 211 Yards and A few Touchdowns After the Time Was About

Bummer, guys.

Winner: The Replacement Philadelphia Eagles

A lot of groups participate in randos Week 17. The Vikings performed Sean Mannion, who experienced just one particular begin at quarterback in his to start with 5 seasons in the NFL, in location of Kirk Cousins. The Bills’ two foremost receivers were being Duke Williams and Tommy Sweeney, who experienced 11 receptions for 184 yards Sunday—they’d formerly mixed for nine occupation receptions. Mike Boone, who had a hundred twenty five yards on the season getting into Sunday, ran for 148 for the Vikings.

The Eagles also played plenty of randos Sunday. Their foremost vast receiver, Deontay Burnett, hadn’t played in an NFL sport considering that very last season when he was on the Jets. Their only obtaining landing of the working day was caught by Joshua Perkins, who hadn’t caught a touchdown considering the fact that 2016, when he performed for the Falcons. (To locate out info on him, you have to Google “Josh Perkins football” because there’s a G League player named Josh Perkins, and G League players are more notable than replacement-level limited ends.) By the finish of the working day, their major jogging back was Boston Scott, who is not a male that identified as into WEEI so often that he got a career as a sidekick for the duration of the drivetime sporting activities-discuss hour, but a 5-foot-six jogging back picked in the sixth round by the Saints very last yr.

But there’s a difference involving the Eagles’ rando squad and gamers like Mannion, Boone, Williams, and Sweeney building appearances. The Eagles experienced every little thing to play for Sunday, as they could clinch the NFC East with a win more than the Giants, but their ability positions have been devastated by accidents. The team’s top rated 3 broad receivers (DeSean Jackson, Alshon Jeffery, and Nelson Agholor), three of their top four functioning backs (Jordan Howard, Corey Clement, and Darren Sproles) and their best restricted close (Zach Ertz) had been out with accidents likely into Sunday’s video game. And midway via the activity, their next running back, Miles Sanders, suffered an injuries as properly.

And so, with the period of the line, the randos ended up a necessity. Perkins, who was cut by the Eagles in August, experienced the first landing capture of the recreation.

Burnett, cut by the Jets and 49ers this yr, made a critical fourth-quarter grab.

But the star was Scott, who led the crew in both of those speeding and obtaining and concluded with 138 yards and three touchdowns. Here’s Scott catching the display screen move that essentially iced the match, like a totally unneeded spin go in the open discipline with no defenders in his way:

Sorry bout the spin move WiFi made the video game lag

— Boston Scott (@BostonScott2) December thirty, 2019

The Eagles won, 34-seventeen, to clinch their postseason berth. I’m not particularly optimistic about their playoff chances—this is a nine-7 workforce that is only in the playoffs due to the fact an NFC East group is confirmed a playoff location, and is now relying on gamers signed off the avenue in essential roles. Even for a workforce with a background of backups carrying out amazing things in the postseason … it appears to be unlikely that these backups are going to do unbelievable matters in the postseason.

The Eagles’ year will probably end with a reduction. But Sunday will give Philadelphia a fond memory of the 2019 season—a day when gamers who had been forged off by other groups emerged as Philadelphia heroes, supplying the team a shot at the championship when no one else was capable of suiting up.