Time to defend India’s secularism

India’s secular construction faces a profound crisis. The Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019, should be turned down for three good reasons. 1st, it is against the letter and spirit of our Structure. 2nd, it is divisive, deeply discriminatory and violative of human legal rights. Third, it seeks to impose the politics and philosophy of Hindutva, with its vision of a “Hindu nation”, on our overall folks and on the simple composition of our polity. Our constitutional values are in peril, and no individual who has faith in our democracy can afford to be silent and uninvolved in what is happening all-around us.

Versus common citizenship

Enable us comprehend every single of these 3 details. The to start with is that the Citizenship (Modification) Act is towards the letter and spirit of our Constitution. Content articles 5 to eleven of the Structure offer with citizenship, and the Citizenship Act, 1955, lays down criteria for citizenship primarily based on beginning, descent, registration, naturalisation, and citizenship by incorporation of territory. By location new criteria, the Citizenship (Modification) Act goes against the premise of common citizenship irrespective of variations of caste, creed, gender, ethnicity and lifestyle. Even further, Article 14 of the Structure lays down that the “State shall not deny to any person equality in advance of the legislation or the equal defense of the legal guidelines in just the territory of India”. It bears emphasis that Write-up 14 applies not only to citizens but to “all individuals in just the territory of India”.

What do we mean by the spirit of the Structure? We affiliate the drafting of our Structure with the abundant debates of the Constituent Assembly, and the wisdom of its members, amongst whom Babasaheb Ambedkar stands tall. It is usually not recognised, having said that, that it was the heroism of hundreds of thousands of unsung freedom fighters that manufactured our Constitution a reality. These men and females, who came from the operating course, peasantry, and socially marginalised groups — what ever their religious persuasion — challenged the colonial authorities in their battle for human legal rights and financial justice. This struggle experienced broader aims than the overthrow of colonial rule. These torchbearers of fashionable Indian background played a critical part in generating the demand for social justice, and a Structure with democratic and secular values in a society in which discrimination and inequality were being deeply ingrained. Though the framing of the Constitution did not mark the stop of the wrestle for civil liberties and for an egalitarian culture, it, however, was a milestone in our heritage.

Our independence fighters have been also acutely aware that theirs was a struggle for a modern society cost-free of caste and spiritual deprivation and discrimination, and cost-free of the deep social and financial inequalities that characterise Indian culture. This was real of the manifestos of the Still left from the early 1920s this aspiration was also mirrored in the resolution of the Karachi session of the Indian Countrywide Congress in 1931, held soon after the execution of Bhagat Singh and his comrades. Confronted by the radical mass upsurge of the time, the Congress passed resolutions on the flexibility of speech, press, flexibility of assembly, independence of association, and equality in advance of the regulation.

The national motion in British India was even more strengthened by movements in the erstwhile princely States. Our forebears dreamt of an unbiased India in which communal prejudice would be alien to the polity. It is not stunning that the threat to people elements of our Structure that defend secularism, democracy, social equality, federalism, and unique and social variety, must occur from that section of the polity that did not participate in the flexibility struggle. The surrender to British imperialism by the precursors of today’s forces of Hindutva, is a chapter of India’s background that is solid in stone. No amount of denial can change that unheroic previous.

Violative of rights

Our 2nd place is that the Citizenship (Amendment) Act is divisive, deeply discriminatory and violative of human rights. As I have composed right before, our countrywide unity was received by battle the Citizenship (Amendment) Act is one particular of the lots of threats to its survival. Our challenging-won Structure recognises person and social variances, and that we ought to weave the wire of unity by generating a sense of belonging and inclusiveness for all.

The Citizenship (Modification) Act attempts to produce and deepen communal division and social polarisation in the nation. The Act gives eligibility for citizenship to Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, Parsis and Christians from Afghanistan, Bangladesh and Pakistan who entered India on or before December 31, 2014, and precisely excludes Muslims from that checklist. In granting citizenship on the basis of faith, it discriminates towards Muslims and rejects the simple principle of secularism.

That the Citizenship (Modification) Act is discriminatory and violative of human legal rights has been recognised by those who have come out on the streets in numerous States, in opposition to the Act. It is noteworthy that university and higher education pupils determine so prominently in the upsurge in opposition to the Act. However pushed by means of in the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha by the Bharatiya Janata Bash (BJP) and its allies, these younger citizens of India have come jointly — a great deal as students did throughout the anti-colonial struggle — to reject the try to divide India alongside spiritual traces. They have denounced this Act as discriminatory and violative of human legal rights.

The Right’s agenda

Our final issue, that the agenda of Hindutva and its top purpose of creating a “Hindu Nation” underlie the Citizenship (Modification) Act, is very well set up the two by past knowledge and the existing actions of the BJP-Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. We stated previously the absence of the forces of Hindutva from the liberty movement. It was in this period of time that M.S. Golwalkar propounded his theory of India as a “Hindu Nation,” where other religious communities experienced no legal rights of citizenship. The Citizenship (Amendment) Act is the newest blow by the BJP to the secular nature of our polity.

When the Remaining has been in Federal government we have designed just about every effort and hard work to use the equipment at our command to preserve communal harmony elsewhere, we have organised the masses to make sure this sort of harmony.

Notes from Kerala

Kerala’s wrestle for secularism and social equality has significantly to teach us. Traditionally, the distinctive strands of Kerala’s social renaissance and, subsequently, the forces of the Left and other progressive sections, fought really hard versus social discrimination and communalism, and for social and economic equality.

All political events and social groupings of unique types in Kerala, other than the functions and organisations of Hindutva, have arrive collectively towards the Citizenship (Modification) Act. The tranquil satyagraha held in Thiruvananthapuram on December 16, attended by political functions, spiritual leaders, and cultural leaders is a image of our united willpower to uphold constitutional values and standard human rights, and to oppose discrimination.

We are not able to postpone our protest and united resistance towards this assault on secularism and democracy.

Pinarayi Vijayan is the Main Minister of Kerala

You have achieved your limit for free of charge articles or blog posts this thirty day period.

Sign-up to The Hindu for totally free and get unrestricted obtain for thirty times.

Subscription Rewards Contain

Present day Paper

Uncover mobile-pleasant edition of content articles from the day’s newspaper in one particular effortless-to-read listing.

Unlimited Obtain

Take pleasure in looking through as lots of content articles as you wish without any limits.

Personalised tips

A find checklist of articles that match your passions and preferences.

More rapidly pages

Move effortlessly amongst content articles as our web pages load promptly.


A just one-cease-store for viewing the most current updates, and managing your preferences.


We transient you on the most current and most important developments, 3 occasions a day.

Not convinced? Know why you ought to pay for information.

*Our Electronic Membership options do not at this time contain the e-paper ,crossword, Iphone, iPad mobile apps and print. Our ideas increase your looking through encounter.